4 comments

  • jerrythegerbil 25 minutes ago
    As a (previous) customer of Proton from many years and a user of their drive product, you should be aware that earlier this year the drive API endpoints began to block their own VPN egress quite often for rate limiting. They also block many cloud provider’s egress. They also don’t officially support rclone, and their changing API spec often breaks the compatibility.

    I saw the writing on the wall and migrated rapidly earlier this year ahead of crypto product launches ahead of the email fiasco. It was hard to get data back out, even then.

    Proton still stands for privacy. But the dark patterns for lock-in I can do without.

    Hetzner Storage boxes with rclone and the “crypt” option are a drop-in replacement, at ~$40 for 20TB. That’s where I went instead.

  • augusto-moura 1 hour ago
    Support for proton drive on rclone is still on beta [1], Proton, AFAIK, doesn't provide documented official APIs for accessing their Drive. Much of the work on the rclone plugin was made via reverse engineering and reading Proton's open source projects code

    [1]: https://rclone.org/protondrive/

    • prism56 1 hour ago
      My rclone for proton stopped working this week and I just cannot get it working. It's looking likely the support will be dropped as the dev is no longer working on it and it's not finished.

      Hopefully proton will hurry up with their SDK. Through the rclone GUI I can access and mount the folders and files but I cannot get any auto rclone commands to actually transfer any files.

    • zacwest 53 minutes ago
      They are working on an SDK, which they will use for their own Linux client: https://proton.me/blog/proton-drive-sdk-preview
  • bjt12345 1 hour ago
    Surely there's better technological solutions for encrypting block data in the cloud with lower risks of service ensh*tification?
    • jszymborski 54 minutes ago
      The state of things isn't great IMHO. Im not sure I trust any of EncFS, CryFS, and gocryptfs.

      Many leak metadata and/or have serious security concerns.

      • karlgkk 41 minutes ago
        Metadata leakage is a fundamental issue when you go from block to object. I can think of some schemes that would help but they’re all kinda nasty lol
        • jszymborski 24 minutes ago
          Of course, and I didnt intend to downplay the efforts of those projects. Just pointing out that they don't meet the requirements of most threat models.
  • Havoc 1 hour ago
    Neat. I did just buy one of their packages so this will be useful